Wires a fourth variant into the Cube-SP × PE-SP long-context decode
composite command-form study to surface the worst-case PE_CPU dispatch
inflation that the coarse composite forms delegate to PE_SCHEDULER
(ADR-0065): per-block DMA of Q/K/V slices, tl.dot per 16³ block,
deferred K-inner sum outside the K loop.
Renamed _tiled.py → _hand_tiled_16x16x16.py; coarse-primitive kernel
retained for the 4-cases bench, paper scripts, and the golden byte-equal
regression guard.
New breakdown bar chart at S_kv=128K shows engine (~460 μs) dominates
all three variants; hand-tiled adds ~68 μs PE_CPU dispatch on top —
composite forms sit essentially on the memory-bound floor.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Complete the composite-command study across both attention regimes and
write up the result, resolving when the composite command helps latency.
Decode (memory-bound, T_q=1, M=8): the command form is latency-neutral —
the kernel is bound by KV streaming and the MAC array is near-idle, so the
composite's only benefit here is host-issue offload (O(n_tiles) -> O(1)
PE_CPU commands). Figure: gqa_decode_long_ctx_composite (latency flat,
command count saturates).
Prefill (compute-bound, large M=G*T_q tile-filling): add three command-form
variants of a single-rank FlashAttention prefill kernel
(_gqa_prefill_compute_bound: primitive / composite / composite_extended).
Here the composite's scheduler-internal per-tile DMA<->compute pipeline
keeps the MAC array fed while the primitive's blocking tl.dot starves it,
so composite wins on MAC utilization (68% flat -> 83%) and wall-clock
(19% faster at ctx=1024), with the margin growing with context (deeper
P.V reduction = more tiles to pipeline) — the compute-bound mirror of the
GEMM result in section 3. Figure: gqa_prefill_compute_bound (latency +
MAC util). Sweep wired as GQA_1H_SWEEPS=prefill_cb; tests cover structure,
e2e, and composite<primitive in the compute-bound regime.
The synthesis: composite has two benefits set by roofline position —
host-issue offload (always) and MAC-array feeding (compute-bound only).
Decode exercises the first, prefill both.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Add two command-form variants of the Case-6 (Cube-SP x PE-SP) long-context
decode kernel alongside the primitive baseline:
- composite: per-tile GEMMs issued as one coarse tl.composite over the
full S_local (PE_SCHEDULER tiles/streams K,V) -- O(1) PE_CPU commands
vs the primitive kernel's O(n_tiles).
- composite_extended: Q.K^T composite + softmax_merge recipe composite
(ADR-0065), folding the per-tile online merge + P.V.
Extract the shared two-level (m,l,O) reduce into _gqa_mlo_reduce and
refactor the baseline to use it (byte-equal, guarded by a 64-rank
command-stream digest test).
Engine fix: _make_compute_out omitted pinned=True, so an on-chip TCM
compute result consumed as a composite GEMM operand was scheduled as an
HBM DMA_READ of its bit-61 scratch address -> PhysAddrError in data mode.
Mark compute outputs pinned (resident), matching the composite
auto-output and recipe scratch handles. .pinned is read only by the
tiling DMA gate, so this is byte-equal for existing benches.
Add the composite sweep (emit-level PE_CPU dispatch to 1M + data-mode
latency to 128K), its plot, umbrella wiring (GQA_1H_SWEEPS=composite),
and tests (refactor guard, dispatch saturation, engine-fix, e2e).
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
mukesh
ywkang